| The AOAI
The Story
Membership
Chapter
Directory News &
Events Magazine E-Newsletter
Forum Resources
AOAI Store
2011 Calendar
Classifieds
Contact Us
|
|
| |
|
Welcome,
all. This is the first
issue of the AOAI E-Newsletter,
which will publish either the
second or third Sunday of every
month. Now and in the future I
will deal with issues relevant
to automotive enthusiasts in
general, but viewed through the
lens of one particularly
interested in the Avanti. For
this first mailing, I have
decided to focus on the future
of classic cars in the midst of
increased government regulation.
Much of the information provided
herein comes from a presentation
given in March of this year by
McKeel Hagerty of Hagerty
Collector Car Insurance; I am
forever grateful for his
insights into these issue and
his continuing attempts to
preserve our rights as
automotive enthusiasts. Finally,
please remember that opinions of
past issues and ideas for future
publications are always welcome.
Enjoy,
Peter
Miller, 63R-4810
|
| * * * |
| |
| Competing Visions
of the Future of the Collector Car |
| |
 |
|
In
July of this year I drove
my ’63 R1 from San Francisco to
St. Louis. It seemed perfectly
natural to spend four days and
2200 miles with my girlfriend in
a forty-seven year old car with
155 thousand miles on an engine
still sporting its original
valve cover seals. Still with an
hint of disbelief I admit that
the car performed most
admirably: from the Oakland Bay
Bridge at sea level to Granby
Pass at roughly 8,000 feet, then
eighty-five miles per hour past
the corn fields all the way
through Kansas our only stops
were for gas, oil, a minor
coolant leak. So wonderfully
successful was the trip that we
are already planning our next on
to Gettysburg for the National
Meet next summer.
Certainly there are others in
this world with similar
experiences in an Avanti, and no
doubt there are others who have
driven yet older and more
significant cars on longer and
more treacherous roads. But one
must ask how common this story
will be one hundred years from
now. Will tomorrow’s owners of
our beloved automobiles still
recognize the same rights,
freedoms, and accessibility to
parts, fuels, and other
peripherals that we do today? A
minute to reflect reveals the
reality that barriers to keeping
an older vehicle on the road
extend far beyond a blown tire
or a malfunctioning fuel pump.
Social, economic, political, and
technological considerations
tender these barriers, and the
potential for our hobby to
someday ‘go the way of the
horse’ is rationale enough to
probe deeper into pertinent
areas.
Nearly half of the world’s six
million cars recognized as
classic or historic vehicles are
located in North America. As far
as government regulations are
concerned, these have generally
flown under the radar, re seat
belt laws for pre-1965 vehicles
and emissions exemptions for
pre-1975 vehicles. Yet
enthusiasts continue to bear the
pains of laws that indirectly
present obstacles to one’s
interests in the field, such as
preservation or customization.
Once epitomizing the hobby, the
near-draconian regulation of the
lacquer paint and tri-chrome
industries is accepted as common
sense given the environmental
impact of these obsolete
technologies. Could the same
reasoning, applied to our cars,
also redefine them as obsolete
and thus relegated solely to
special, paved “horse paths”,
or, even worse, solely to static
displays?
The period of 1965 through
1980, wrought with recession,
worldwide ethnic tensions, and
strong anti-war sentiment, saw a
vast increase in government
power: a three-fold increase in
regulatory statutes followed a
two-fold increase in government
regulating agencies in the
United States. From this period
arose Medicare, Medicaid, the
EPA, and CAFÉ standards, amongst
other public health and consumer
protection laws. If the
economic, political, and social
conditions of a country are any
indication of its inclination to
pass more regulatory measures,
then the collector car community
should expect some degree of
relevant regulatory change in
the near term. With many states
in the Union still running
extensive deficits, some state
taxes and fees are likely to
rise, and given the growing
social frustrations with
pollution and the bias against
privately-owned vehicles, it is
likely that the collector car
will no longer be so easily
overlooked as a source for state
and federal tax revenue.
And in very short time indeed
the social norms regarding
transportation in this country
changed. Only ten years ago the
GM Suburban line and the Ford
F-series pickups were still
top-selling vehicles in North
America. Today, hybrid cars from
Japan and diesels from Germany
are enticing buyers with 50+
mpg- and low-emission-ratings
from the EPA. Hybrids are now
given free-reign in the carpool
lanes in California and do not
pay for parking in certain areas
of Los Angeles. In taking the
next step to reduce carbon
emissions from privately-owned
vehicles, the House
Transportation Committee has
appropriated tens of billions of
dollars for public
transportation in major cities
throughout the country, and
local and state governments are
pushing the same initiatives to
“coerce people out of their
cars.” Although Americans will
not transition to a public
transport society overnight, one
would be blind not to recognize
the possibility in future
generations.
As it has been for decades now,
emissions concerns will continue
to be at the forefront of
transportation policy
internationally well into the
future. Although other
greenhouse gases – such as
methane – are far more
detrimental to the environment,
the social fixation with carbon
dioxide and the regulation of
the automotive and manufacturing
industries extant renders
additional statues in these
fields more easily passed and
enforced than, say, the
regulation of beef production.
Many governments are passing
evermore restrictive laws on
higher-emission-producing
vehicles. In fact, Arizona
recently attempted to pass
legislation that would have
removed most collector cars
entirely from Arizona roads due
to their relatively high
emissions outputs. Luckily
enough,
Hagerty Collector Car
Insurance used an EPA
study to show that collector
cars make up only a very small
percentage of carbon emissions
in the state; this, coupled with
hints of crippling economic
ramifications, prevented
passage of the law. In
this case, the EPA aided the
cause of the automotive
enthusiast, but current events
suggest this will not always be
the case. Within the last year,
as part of the Clean Air Act,
the EPA gained the power to
promulgate new emissions laws
based on an Endangerment
Finding that was not
struck down by the Supreme
Court; now the EPA competes with
Congress to achieve the carbon
emissions reduction goals of the
current administration. While
Congress admits that it feels
itself in a better position to
regulate in this realm, it
recognizes openly that the
pressure induced by competition
between these offices is healthy
insofar as it produces increased
attention that will certainly
lead to quicker resolution. Yes,
there will be more regulation of
our hobby, but how much?
Finally, in this new era of
social regulation where social
perception pervades government
legislation and public policy,
the future of oil also comes
into question. With such chaos
throughout the Gulf of Mexico,
the American public displays an
ever-increasing distrust of oil,
oil companies, and the
associated peripheral
entities. This only exacerbates
the public desire to implement
alternative energies,
particularly as international
tensions from South America to
the Middle East are unlikely to
improve in the near future. In
the long run, the mere
availability of gasoline is in
question, but today a more
pressing issue centers on
ethanol-based fuels. Studies
show that our classic cars will
continue to function sans
difficulty even with fuels
containing some small proportion
of ethanol, but E-85 and even
higher-proportion bio-fuel /
gasoline mixtures are sure to
pose a problem. One would be
remiss to neglect the strong
likelihood high ethanol content
in gasoline becoming the norm in
the mid- to long-term. One may
be surprised, however, to know
that a recent bill preventing
the disclosure of ethanol
composition in gasoline almost
became federal law. This stands
in direct opposition to the
concept of preserving older
vehicles, as well as the right
to drive them. It is seemingly
minor regulatory actions such as
these that pose some of the
greatest hurdles for the
enthusiast of the future.
|
 |
|
But
what does all of this mean,
and what room is left for the
enthusiast to effect change
beneficial to the collector car
community? First and foremost,
it is high time for enthusiasts
to hold themselves to a higher
ethical standard than has been
acceptable in the past. I am not
sure to what extent this is
relevant to members of the AOAI,
but, in particular,
falsification of vehicle
identification numbers has
plagued the hobby at all levels
for decades – how many ’32 Fords
actually rolled off of the
assembly line in Dearborn in
1932? And which of those hundred
or so Mercedes SSKs currently
registered with the European Fédération
Internationale des Véhicules
Anciens as authentic is
one of the original thirty-one
produced in Stuttgart by Mercede
Benz craftsman? Deceitful
actions of this nature breed
distrust, particularly from
persons outside of the
community, and the hobby will be
unable to afford this type of
behavior for much longer.
I use the phrase 'collector car
community' to suggest that, in
fact, automotive enthusiasts
have a lot in common and should
continue to embrace the shared
interest in prolonging the right
and ability to drive their old
cars. In the past, my
relationship with my Avanti
influenced my own dissociation
from Mustang and Corvette
owners, but I now realize this
childish reaction to competition
for the coolest American sports
car of the 1960s is quickly
surpassed by a more important
need to come together under a
common interest in collector
cars; by uniting under this
cause our voices grow louder and
our political influence greater,
perhaps to the extent that
someday we overcome the most
restrictive of state or federal
regulations. This is precisely
the direction of the
Historic Vehicle Association
(HVA), as the hundreds of
thousands of collector car
owners in the United States pose
as a significant special
interest group, and the billions
of dollars spent annually in the
aftermarket and restoration
services industries grant them
significant financial influence.
That said, I encourage all
members of the AOAI to peruse
the HVA website and to decide
for themselves what level of
support they wish to offer, if
any, both now and in the future.
If one resides himself to
confidence in the power of
numbers, then the continued
provocation of an interest in
old cars amongst younger
generations must be a prime
consideration of current members
of the community. I am convinced
that the preservation of the
collector car lifestyle is
contingent upon the preservation
of this interest. But this also
indicates a necessity for
reevaluation of the purpose of
the collector car community.
Perhaps this becomes a hobby
less focused on going fast,
cruising, or buffing paint, and
rather adopts an ideal of
maintenance and preservation of
historical artifacts paramount
to protecting a heritage of
innovation, design, and
manufacturing for future
generations. Although one may
argue that there will always be
a place for high speed on four
wheels or perfect chrome under a
hot sun, such a change in
perspective may increase the
accessibility of collector cars
to an otherwise disinterested
crowd, and in so doing grow the
involvement in the collector car
world.
|
 |
|
Admittedly,
I have painted a rather
drab picture of the future of
the collector car hobby; but, in
fact, quite the opposite is
true. The AOAI continues to
grow, both in new members and
local chapters; a younger
generation is taking a more
active role in the club;
historically significant
artifacts relevant to the Avanti
are surfacing and made publicly
available thanks to
contributions from the AOAI. The
club is poised for success and
continued growth in the future,
and members should relish this
fact. But one should not be
glib, and I implore all to keep
in mind the issues discussed
above. At the moment, the
situation is far from dire, but
enthusiasts throughout the world
should strive to preserve both
these cars and the right to
drive them for the sake of
future generations. After all,
we are but caretakers of
history.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Welcome
to the AOAI Newletter! |
| |
| The purpose
of this publication is to inform the AOAI
community of isues pertiinent to our club,
our marque, and our hobby in general. |
| |
| The intended audience of
this AOAI Newsletter extends beyond the
AOAI community, as its contents are
relevant to automobile enthusiasts the
world over. |
| |
| Distribution of this
Newletters is not only permitted but
highly encouraged. Opinions and
subscription requests should be addressed
to petermiller@aoai.org. |
| |
| If viewing in a web
browser, use [Ctrl] + [-] to adjust page
fit. |
|
|